Aristotle’s Model the Play as a Whole - 1469 Words

Aristotle’s Model: The Play as a Whole In Aristotle’s Poetics, Aristotle emphasizes three major elements of a good play: plot, character, and thought. To be more specific, in an Aristotelian play, thought sets the cause of action with character as emotion developer based on plot as the basic form. Besides these three main factors, the idea that a play should be a complete whole is also the basis of the Poetics (Aristotle 61). Therefore, when comparing the choices Lobby Hero by Kenneth Lonergan and The Philadelphia Story by Philip Barry for the play of the season, unification and regularity of all three elements. After comparing and contrasting both plays, Lobby Hero fits the Aristotle’s model’s three elements, plot, character and thought†¦show more content†¦Although Jeff does not indicate any sign about truth telling, his habit of telling truth is embedded in the details of the play. When Jeff hears Bill lying to Dawn about his fair with Mrs. Heinvald, he intentionally calls Bill to pick up his hat left in Mrs. Heinvald’s apartment. His audacious and straightforward speaking routine also makes the final truth telling consistent with his characteristics. Acknowledged that William is his superintendent, he is still dare to talk about his sexual illusion about female cop. With a faith of telling the truth and frank talking behavior, telling Dawn about William’s brother’s crime is consistent to Jeff’s personality. In this way, Lobby Hero well constructs a character with great consistency whose actions hold the play into a rational whole story. If Lobby Hero’s Jeff is consistent in his consistency, Tracy in The Philadelphia Story is inconsistent in her consistency. Tracy is inconsistent because her sensitivity is changing. She sees George as an angel the day before the wedding but falls crazily in love with Mike, or Macaulay, and his books the night before the wedding. However, when she looks at the â€Å"boat of true love†, Tracy b egins to think of the good time spent with Dexter. Under the presumption that Tracy is a very unstable character, the abrupt ending seems plausible. Therefore, Tracy isShow MoreRelatedDeath of a Salesman and Oedipus Rex1348 Words   |  5 Pagescan identify the source of his downfall. In Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman’s character refutes Aristotle’s theory, as he is notorious for blinding himself from the truth which appears quite obvious to others around him. As a salesman throughout his life, Willy’s set his life’s goals on materialistic things and ultimately he does not achieve those goals. Distinctly opposite to Willy, Oedipus in the play Oedipus Rex enters life, as a nobleman who inherits his wealth. Although both characters experienceRead MoreOedipus Rex, Sophocles1252 Words   |  6 Pages Liberty University Abstract In the play Oedipus Rex, Sophocles portrays Oedipus who is also the main character, as a good- natured, beautiful, noble yet narcissistic person who has a lapse of judgment and fall from power. Throughout the play Oedipus makes a few profound decisions for which he is condemned to plentiful suffering; thus making Oedipus fit the mold of a tragic hero if we agreeRead MoreThe Greek Philosophers And The Philosophers1422 Words   |  6 Pagesdescribe the universe, and objects as a whole to describe the universe. Plato was a philosopher from about 429 – 347 BC. In studying natural principles, Plato focused on the intellectual world and the soul. He believed that everything in the universe could be described by intellect. He believed in three fundamental ideas. These three ideas, truth, justice, and good, played predominant roles in what he taught his students. One of Plato’s best known works is a play with the title of Caves. This is takenRead MoreDemocracy : An Ideal State A Model For Future Societies1095 Words   |  5 Pagesown right to power. Aristotle felt that every state is a community and that these communities are established to produce some good in his work The Politics. The Republic, Plato felt that through philosophical teaching to establish the ideal state—a model for future societies. Plato’s method would be an ideal way to settle the controversy when dealing with democracy, Aristotle solution interrelates with Plato’s method. Plato felt that when the poor overcomes the rich it then becomes a democracy. ThisRead MoreHamlet Tragic Flaw Analysis1522 Words   |  7 Pagesever written, and it has sparked a few controversial discussions amongst critics, the most intriguing topic being Hamlet’s ‘tragic flaw’. It was A.C. Bradley who popularised this concept of a ‘tragic flaw’ which was translated and based around Aristotle’s model of tragedy. He suggests that the reason Hamlet delayed the act of avenging his father’s murder was due to possessing a tragic flaw; the inability to act. Whereas, critic James P. Hammersmith, suggests that the Aristotelian concept of the ‘tragicRead MoreWho Knows1685 Words   |  7 Pagestheory and practice in the light of Aristotles influential categorization of knowledge into three disciplines: the theoretical, the practical and the productive. [pic] (Praxis: informed, committed action) The body of knowledge or syllabus to be transmitted is that traditionally referred to as the canon; the process and praxis models come close to practical deliberation; and the technical concerns of the outcome or product model mirror elements of Aristotles definition of the productive. ChangingRead MoreSexual Morality and Social Context1707 Words   |  7 PagesSexual Morality â€Å"There must be integrity between body and life. You must not do with your body what you’re not willing to do with your whole life† (Keller). Keller is directly talking about our individual sexual morality and how or how not it should be perceived in a social context. Most people think sexual dilemmas of it in a broader spectrum, not directly related to one’s morality, by saying â€Å"this act isn’t right† where others may simply say â€Å"why not†. Yet, what justifies an act for one personRead MoreThe Tragic Hero Of Oedipus Rex, And Willie Loman1204 Words   |  5 Pagesgetting what was coming to him, karma, if you will. Although Oedipus, Othello, and Willie Loman can all be said to fall within Aristotle’s definition of a tragic hero, each represents a very different interpretation of the concept. Oedipus, the tragic hero of Oedipus Rex, written by the ancient Greek playwright Sophocles, is inarguably a tragic hero. In fact, Oedipus was the model which Aristotle used to define tragic heroes. Oedipus’ story certainly is tragic. After going on a manhunt to find theRead MorePast and Present of Civil Relations1931 Words   |  8 Pagesgood purpose-- on the end product of what we set our minds to. This is where the five components of civic relationships come in; each one plays a key role in order to solve this equation of seeking the greatest good. In this case, we will analyze, compare and contrast exactly what the greatest good in civic relationships consists of and see in what ways Aristotle’s ideas are similar and different to the perceptions of successful, present day workplaces in the United States according to Great Place toRead MoreGreek Mythology And Mythology Of The Iliad, Oedipus Rex And Others1294 Words   |  6 Pagesof Greek mythology and narrative s plays a significant role in shaping the arts, most notably dance and performance. It also prompted the Aristotle Poetics that discussed the value of six specific traits in every tragedy. It has even encouraged the usage in other fields of study, the most notably the existence of the Oedipus complex. The inclusion of different narratives, and symbolisms help to create a more dynamic environment in which the performance as a whole seems more complete. Sophocles’ Oedipus